Top 11 Underrated Horror Novels in 2026

2026 Edition

Updated January 27, 2026

Editor's Picks

11 Novels

Horror in web novels ranges from psychological dread to cosmic terror to survival scenarios. Finding genuinely scary writing that maintains quality throughout takes curation. These underrated picks earned strong ratings from readers who found them while remaining less visible than their quality suggests.

What you'll find varies in approach. Some build slow atmospheric dread. Others deliver visceral terror. A few explore psychological horror that unsettles through implication rather than explicit content. The common thread is taking the genre seriously rather than using horror elements as background decoration.

1
TOP PICK
Dungeon Defense
4.5
(3.0K ratings)
Genre: action, drama, ecchi
Do you know how this world ends? Become the hero and defeat the 72 Demon Lords.
First Impressions
Dungeon Defense is a web novel that certainly sparked a lot of strong opinions, and after diving in, I can see why. It's a story about a protagonist who transmigrates into a game he's beaten, becoming the weakest demon lord, Dantalian. He has to use his wits and cunning to survive and rise in a world filled with scheming nobles and powerful enemies. Initially, I was hooked by the premise. The idea of an intelligent, manipulative main character in a fantasy setting is always appealing. The first volume seemed to set up a fascinating world of political intrigue and strategic battles, and I found...
Read More
Completed
2
RUNNER UP
Kaleidoscope of Death
4.6
(1.3K ratings)
Genre: comedy, horror, mystery
It started off peculiarly; first, his domestic cat refused to let him cuddle it. Lin Qiushi soon found that a sense of disharmony and incongruity began to pervade everything around him.
First Impressions
"Kaleidoscope of Death" is a wild ride, and I mean wild. I went into this expecting a horror novel with some romance, and I got that, but it was so much more complex and thought-provoking than I initially anticipated. Buckle up, because this novel will take you on a journey through some truly terrifying and mind-bending scenarios. Right off the bat, the novel is incredibly engaging. It throws you headfirst into the action, and the descriptions are vivid and unsettling. I found myself genuinely creeped out at times, which is exactly what I want from a horror story. The premise of entering these...
Read More
Completed
3
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
Thriller Trainee
4.6
(696 ratings)
Genre: action, fantasy, horror
The washed-up magician Zong Jiu transmigrated into a horror, infinite flow novel about a survival show, taking the place of the cannon fodder who died tragically in the first evaluation round. This show was very interesting.
First Impressions
"Thriller Trainee" is a web novel that throws you headfirst into a world of transmigration, infinite loops, and deadly games. I was intrigued by the premise – a blend of action, horror, and even a dash of romance (yaoi, to be specific). While the overall rating is quite high, my experience was a bit more nuanced than a simple thumbs-up. The initial chapters definitely grabbed my attention. The idea of a magician thrust into a series of increasingly dangerous "instances" was compelling. I was eager to see how the protagonist, with his supposed antisocial tendencies, would navigate this bizarre ...
Read More
Completed
4
EDITORS CHOICE
They All Say I’ve Met a Ghost
4.6
(649 ratings)
Genre: comedy, horror, romance
Hello, everyone! My name is Shen Jianguo.
First Impressions
"They All Say I’ve Met a Ghost" is a delightful surprise, a blend of comedy, horror, romance, and slice-of-life that I thoroughly enjoyed. It's a story about a righteous teacher who, in his unwavering belief in science and Marxism, refuses to believe in ghosts, even when surrounded by them. The premise alone had me hooked, and the execution didn't disappoint. From the very beginning, the humor shines. The protagonist, Shen Jianguo, is incredibly dense, hilariously rationalizing every supernatural occurrence with logic and scientific explanations. I found myself constantly laughing at his antic...
Read More
Completed
5
EDITORS CHOICE
Card Room
4.5
(648 ratings)
Genre: action, adventure, comedy
Xiao Lou was killed in an accident and reborn in the Card World. Each card here represents a secret room and clearing the instance will give a reward.
First Impressions
"Card Room" is a web novel that throws you headfirst into a deadly game of survival, wrapped in a package of mysteries, puzzles, and just a touch of romance. As someone who enjoys a good blend of genres, I was intrigued by the premise, and overall, I found it to be a compelling read, though not without its quirks. The initial chapters hooked me with their clever blend of escape room scenarios and crime-solving. The premise of a forensic doctor and a police chief teaming up in a deadly card game world is definitely unique. I found myself drawn in by the mysteries and the budding partnership bet...
Read More

Novel Translator 2026

Enjoying Horror Stories?

Unlock horror novels from any language with professional-quality AI translation.

40+ Languages

Translate to and from major world languages

Custom Made Translation Engine

State-of-the-art translation quality

EPUB and TXT Support

Keep formatting, chapters, and covers

Fast Processing

Translate entire novels in hours

View Pricing

Trusted by 16,000+ readers worldwide in 2026

Completed
6
#6 PICK
My House of Horrors
4.6
(647 ratings)
Genre: action, adventure, horror
After the disappearance of his parents, Chen Ge inherits the family-run haunted house attraction at an amusement park. Struggling to bring in customers, he discovers a black phone that grants him the chance to improve his haunted house with expanded scenarios, mastery of skills, the possibility ...
First Impressions
"My House of Horrors" is a wild ride, a blend of genres that somehow manages to be both terrifying and hilarious. It's a novel that grabbed me from the start with its unique premise and kept me hooked, even when it stumbled a bit along the way. The initial concept is undeniably genius: a young man inherits a haunted house attraction and a mysterious phone, leading him into a supernatural world. I was immediately drawn in by the protagonist, Chen Ge, a plucky and resourceful guy who has to navigate increasingly dangerous situations with nothing but his wits and a healthy dose of bravado. It's a...
Read More

Conclusion

Underrated horror rewards readers seeking genuine scares. These eleven found smaller audiences due to the niche nature of quality horror rather than lack of merit. Worth exploring if you want more than typical horror-adjacent fantasy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Our rankings combine reader ratings (40%), popularity metrics (25%), engagement data (20%), and editorial review (15%). We update rankings quarterly to reflect the latest reader sentiments.

The best horror novels excel in their genre-specific elements while delivering compelling characters and plots. Reader satisfaction and re-readability are key factors in our selection.

We update our rankings quarterly throughout 2026 to incorporate new releases, changing reader preferences, and updated rating data.

How We Create Our 2026 Rankings

Our 2026 novel rankings are created through a comprehensive, data-driven process that combines quantitative metrics with qualitative editorial review. Here's how we ensure our rankings reflect the best novels available today.

Data Collection

We aggregate reading data, ratings, and engagement metrics from thousands of readers across multiple platforms, updated regularly throughout 2026.

Community Input

Reader ratings and reviews form the foundation of our rankings. We weight votes based on verified reading history to ensure authenticity.

Quality Scoring

Each novel receives a composite score based on average rating, vote count, reading list additions, and reader retention metrics.

Editorial Review

Our editorial team reviews top candidates for writing quality, translation accuracy, and overall reader experience.

Regular Updates

Rankings are refreshed quarterly to reflect new releases, updated ratings, and shifting reader preferences in 2026.

Transparency

We publish our methodology openly so readers understand exactly how novels earn their positions in our rankings.

Our 2026 Ranking Criteria

40%Reader Rating Score (weighted by vote count and recency)
25%Popularity Metrics (reading list additions, active readers)
20%Engagement Score (comments, reviews, recommendations)
15%Editorial Assessment (writing quality, translation, completeness)

Last updated: January 27, 2026 | Rankings reflect data collected through 2026

Ranked Novels

Dungeon Defense

First Impressions

Kaleidoscope of Death

First Impressions

Thriller Trainee

First Impressions

They All Say I’ve Met a Ghost

First Impressions

Card Room

First Impressions