[TS] Pretty Girl Guitarist’s Notes

My Thoughts on [TS] Pretty Girl Guitarist’s Notes

[TS] Pretty Girl Guitarist’s Notes is a web novel that piqued my interest with its blend of gender bender, music, and slice-of-life elements. The premise, a seasoned guitarist reincarnated as a high school girl, definitely has potential for both comedic and heartwarming moments. After diving in, I have some thoughts.

First Impressions

The initial setup is intriguing. We have Myeong-jeon, a guitarist who's lived the rockstar life, only to realize his music lacked that special something. Waking up as a young woman in a hospital after a coma is quite the wake-up call! The synopsis does leave a bit to be desired, but thankfully the story itself is a bit more engaging.

What Works Well

The core appeal lies in the protagonist rediscovering the joy of music. The slow-paced nature of the story allows for character development and exploration of the slice-of-life aspects. The idea of an all-girls band forming and navigating the music scene is inherently appealing. The "Mary Sue" nature of the MC, while potentially a drawback for some, can also be a source of wish fulfillment for readers who enjoy seeing a character excel.

Areas of Concern

Unfortunately, there are some noticeable issues. The translation quality seems to be a significant hurdle, with reports of incorrect names, pronouns, and even repeated passages. This can definitely disrupt the reading experience and make it difficult to fully immerse oneself in the story. I also found the protagonist's disconnect from her new female identity to be a bit jarring. While the "old soul in a new body" trope is common, the lack of adjustment or exploration of the gender-bending aspect feels like a missed opportunity. The MC's boomer tendencies, while potentially humorous, might also make it harder for some readers to connect with her.

Final Verdict

[TS] Pretty Girl Guitarist’s Notes is a mixed bag. The premise is interesting, and the slice-of-life and music elements have the potential to be quite enjoyable. However, the translation issues and the protagonist's somewhat detached perspective on her new identity are significant drawbacks. If you're a fan of the genre and willing to overlook these flaws, you might find something to enjoy. However, proceed with caution and be prepared for a potentially bumpy ride. I'd give it a tentative 3/5.