I’m Telling You, I’m Not Eligible for Adoption!

My Thoughts on I’m Telling You, I’m Not Eligible for Adoption!

This web novel, "I'm Telling You, I'm Not Eligible for Adoption!," definitely presents an interesting premise, blending fantasy, gender bender elements, and a slice-of-life feel. However, it seems that the execution doesn't quite live up to its potential, at least based on what I've gathered so far.

First Impressions

The initial chapters appear to be a bit rocky. The protagonist, who undergoes age regression and a gender change, seems to rub some readers the wrong way. I can see how the MC's initial stubbornness and insistence on maintaining a "manly man" persona despite being a child could be grating for some. The logic behind some of the early actions, like the wood-selling venture, also seems questionable and a bit rushed.

What Works Well

Despite the initial hurdles, the story seems to find its footing as it progresses. The slice-of-life elements, particularly the development of the orphanage, seem to be a strong point. The found-family dynamic and the protagonist's interactions with the villagers are often described as fluffy and heartwarming. The unique concept itself is also a definite draw, setting it apart from other isekai stories.

Areas of Concern

Unfortunately, some plot developments raise significant red flags. The introduction of the female hero and her… questionable… obsession with the protagonist is a major point of contention. The implications of an adult character turning into a child to pursue a relationship with the MC are disturbing. It introduces a potentially uncomfortable undertone that overshadows the otherwise wholesome aspects of the story. This character's actions and motivations make it difficult to fully enjoy the slice-of-life elements, as it casts a shadow over the interactions between the protagonist and the other characters.

Final Verdict

"I'm Telling You, I'm Not Eligible for Adoption!" has the potential to be a heartwarming and unique story. The initial chapters might require some patience, and the introduction of certain characters could be a deal-breaker for many. If you're willing to overlook the problematic elements and focus on the slice-of-life aspects, there might be some enjoyment to be found here. However, proceed with caution and be aware of the potentially disturbing themes that emerge later in the story.