I’m Not a Saint, Not a Priest, Just a Healer Novel Review

My Thoughts on I’m Not a Saint, Not a Priest, Just a Healer

This web novel, "I’m Not a Saint, Not a Priest, Just a Healer," definitely had an interesting premise that caught my attention, but ultimately, it left me with mixed feelings. The initial setup promised a unique take on the fantasy genre, but some key issues prevented me from fully enjoying the experience.

First Impressions

I can see why some readers might struggle to get hooked right away. The story throws you into the thick of things without much preamble, which can be disorienting. While some prefer this approach, I personally felt a bit lost and wished for a more gradual introduction to the world and characters. It felt like I was missing crucial context to truly appreciate the narrative.

What Works Well

The core concept of the healer class having to physically touch their patients to heal them is intriguing. It adds a layer of risk and intimacy to the traditional party dynamic. The author's attempt to subvert the typical "stand back and heal" trope is commendable, even if the execution isn't always perfect. The idea of healers clinging to tanks during combat creates an interesting visual, though I question its practicality.

Areas of Concern

My biggest reservation lies with the handling of the gender bender aspect. While I appreciate the author's willingness to explore the protagonist's desire to revert to their original gender, the reactions of the supporting characters are troubling. Treating the protagonist's identity as a mere quirk or a symptom of trauma diminishes the validity of their feelings and experiences. This is especially concerning when the protagonist is actively seeking a solution, only to face resistance and potential sabotage from their friends. This plot point introduces uncomfortable implications that significantly detract from the overall narrative. It left me questioning the motivations and values of the characters I was supposed to be rooting for.

Final Verdict

"I’m Not a Saint, Not a Priest, Just a Healer" has some promising elements, particularly in its unique take on the healer class. However, the questionable handling of the gender bender aspect and the potentially problematic actions of the supporting characters ultimately overshadow the novel's strengths. While the initial concept is intriguing, the execution falls short of its potential, leaving me with a sense of disappointment.