I Taught You Carefully, So Why Are You Obsessed?

My Thoughts on I Taught You Carefully, So Why Are You Obsessed?

"I Taught You Carefully, So Why Are You Obsessed?" promised a fun twist on the transmigration trope, and while it had glimmers of potential, I ultimately found myself struggling to connect with the story. The premise, involving a protagonist who enters a novel she read and tries to "fix" the male lead for the original female lead, is certainly intriguing. However, the execution left me with mixed feelings.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the European ambience and the promise of a comedic romance with a strong female lead. The idea of a character actively trying to shape the male lead's personality held a certain appeal, offering the potential for witty banter and unexpected developments.

What Works Well

The novel appears to excel in its portrayal of the supporting female characters. I found the positive depiction of these women refreshing, and it added a layer of depth to the world-building. The initial translation quality also seemed to be a strong point, allowing for a smoother reading experience in the earlier chapters.

Areas of Concern

My biggest issue lies with the female lead's characterization. Her thought process often felt toxic and immature. Her pre-conceived hatred for the male lead, based solely on the original novel's plot, seemed excessive and lacked nuance. I struggled to understand her motivations and found her actions to be condescending and arrogant. Her plan to essentially "train" the male lead before handing him off to the original female lead struck me as particularly problematic and showed a lack of respect for the characters' autonomy and feelings. This made it difficult for me to empathize with her or root for her success.

Final Verdict

While "I Taught You Carefully, So Why Are You Obsessed?" has a unique premise and some positive elements, the problematic characterization of the female lead and the questionable plot choices ultimately hindered my enjoyment. The novel's focus on comedy and romance is overshadowed by the FL's toxic thought process, which is why I can only give this novel a 2.5/5 rating.