Citadel of Desire Novel Review

My Thoughts on Citadel of Desire

"Citadel of Desire" is a web novel that certainly evokes strong reactions, and after diving into it, I can see why. This story blends fantasy, mystery, romance, and a healthy dose of mature content, creating a reading experience that's both intriguing and, at times, a bit unsettling.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the European-esque setting and the promise of a "Beauty and the Beast" kind of vibe. The premise of a seemingly weak female lead finding herself in a strange and potentially dangerous situation definitely piqued my interest. The early chapters hinted at a sensitive and intuitive protagonist, Rei, who could sense the unease surrounding her, which made me think she would be very proactive later in the story.

What Works Well

The male lead, Clodan, is undeniably a compelling character, even if he's a bit of a controversial figure. Many seem to enjoy his beastly and direct approach, as well as the mystery surrounding him. The story also delves into Rei's backstory, revealing the unfair treatment she's endured, which makes you sympathize with her plight and root for her to overcome her challenges. I did enjoy the ML teaching the FL how to read and write, there were some sweet and tender moments to be had.

Areas of Concern

However, I did notice some significant concerns that many readers share. The female lead's agency seems to diminish as the story progresses, which can be frustrating. Some feel she becomes overly naive and her actions don't always make sense, especially given her initial perceptiveness. The insta-love aspect of her attraction to Clodan also feels rushed and somewhat unearned. Additionally, the ML's behavior can be interpreted as problematic, with some labeling him as overly aggressive and even bordering on abusive.

Final Verdict

"Citadel of Desire" is a mixed bag. While the story has moments of captivating mystery, steamy romance, and potential for character development, it's also marred by issues surrounding the female lead's agency and the male lead's questionable behavior. If you're a fan of dark fantasy with mature themes and are willing to overlook some potentially problematic elements, you might find something to enjoy here. However, proceed with caution and be aware of the concerns raised by other readers. Ultimately, I'd give it a cautious recommendation, urging readers to approach it with a critical eye.