[You’re Out] I Was Kicked Out of the Band Just Before My Debut and My Girlfriend Was Stolen, So I Was Planning to Sing Alone, but for Some Reason I Was Surrounded by S Class Beauties

My Thoughts on [You’re Out] I Was Kicked Out of the Band Just Before My Debut and My Girlfriend Was Stolen, So I Was Planning to Sing Alone, but for Some Reason I Was Surrounded by S Class Beauties

Alright, let's dive into this title. Honestly, the name alone is a mouthful, and after reading a chunk of it, I'm still trying to figure out if the story lives up to the hype... or the length of the title.

First Impressions

The premise is certainly attention-grabbing. Betrayal, lost dreams, and then… a harem of "S Class Beauties"? It screams wish fulfillment, and I went in expecting a light, fluffy read. The initial chapters definitely deliver on that promise, setting the stage for our protagonist's fall from grace and the beginning of his unexpected rise.

What Works Well

The initial setup, with the protagonist getting the rug pulled out from under him, is compelling. There's a clear sense of injustice that makes you want to root for him. The music elements are also pretty engaging, and I enjoyed the descriptions of his performances. It's easy to get caught up in the idea of him finding success despite the odds.

Areas of Concern

However, I have to be honest, the execution feels a bit… uneven. The biggest issue I have is with the protagonist himself. While I understand the desire to create a "nice guy" character, he sometimes comes across as frustratingly passive. His willingness to forgive those who wronged him, while admirable in theory, felt a little unrealistic and even annoying at times. It's hard to stay invested when the main character doesn't seem to have the fire to fight for himself. And while the harem aspect might appeal to some, it felt a bit forced and detracted from the overall narrative for me. The relationships didn't feel particularly deep or meaningful, more like a collection of tropes than genuine connections.

Final Verdict

[You’re Out] has a captivating premise and some genuinely enjoyable moments, particularly related to the music. However, the protagonist's frustrating passivity and the somewhat shallow harem elements hold it back. If you're looking for a purely lighthearted, wish-fulfillment read, you might find something to enjoy here. But if you're hoping for a nuanced story with compelling character development, you might be left wanting more.