I’ve Been Kicked Out of an S-Rank Guild. But Only I Can Communicate With Dragons. Before I Knew It, I Became the Greatest Dragon Knight

My Thoughts on I’ve Been Kicked Out of an S-Rank Guild. But Only I Can Communicate With Dragons. Before I Knew It, I Became the Greatest Dragon Knight

Okay, let's dive into "I’ve Been Kicked Out of an S-Rank Guild. But Only I Can Communicate With Dragons. Before I Knew It, I Became the Greatest Dragon Knight." That title is definitely a mouthful, and honestly, it did give me pause before I even started reading. But hey, I'm always willing to give a story a shot.

First Impressions

The initial setup, with the MC being ostracized despite his unique ability to connect with dragons, definitely had some promise. I was intrigued by the idea of a world where dragons are commonplace but misunderstood, and the protagonist being the only one who truly sees their sentience.

What Works Well

Some readers found the beginning quite engaging, particularly the interactions between the MC and the dragons. The idea of dragons being treated as mere beasts of burden, and the MC's compassionate approach, resonated with me. I also appreciated the potential for a "slice-of-life" feel, with the promise of escalating drama later on. A few readers also enjoyed the MC's character, finding him rational and likable.

Areas of Concern

However, I have to acknowledge the significant criticisms leveled against this novel. A recurring theme is the perceived lack of depth in the world-building. Several readers felt the world was populated with characters who were inexplicably unintelligent or cruel, seemingly only to make the MC look better by comparison. This, coupled with plot conveniences and inconsistencies, detracted from the overall experience for many.

Another point of contention is the direction the story takes later on. Some felt the focus shifted away from the dragons themselves, reducing them to mere accessories in a harem, and the MC's acquisition of overpowered abilities felt unearned and detrimental to the narrative.

Final Verdict

Ultimately, my impression of "I’ve Been Kicked Out of an S-Rank Guild..." is mixed. While the initial concept and the MC's interactions with dragons offer some appeal, the execution seems to falter significantly as the story progresses. The shallow world-building, plot inconsistencies, and shift in focus away from the dragons themselves are major drawbacks. If you're looking for a light, brain-off read with a dragon-centric harem, this might be your cup of tea. However, if you're seeking a well-developed world, consistent plot, and meaningful character development, you might want to look elsewhere.